Teeny Awards

Teeny Awards Nominees 2025 (Winners in Bold)

Lead Role in a Play, Comedy-TIE

• Daniella Andrango in the role of Sir Henry in “Baskerville” at Pierson High School
• Emma Binkis in the role of Daria Chase in “The Game’s Afoot: Holmes for the Holidays” at Southold High School
• Ava Catania in the role of Martina Vanderhof (Grandma) in “You Can’t Take It With You” at Mattituck High School
• Cameron Hipp in the role of Colonel Mustard in “Clue” at Westhampton Beach High School
• Jackie Iulo in the role of Sherlock Holmes in “Baskerville” at Pierson High School
• Alex Kennedy in the role of William Gillette in “The Game’s Afoot: Holmes for the Holidays” at Southold High School
• Ava Kuklis in the role of Mrs. Peacock in “Clue” at Westhampton Beach High School
• Meghan Pomroy in the role of Wadsworth in “Clue” at Westhampton Beach High School
• Sabrina McManus in the role of John Watson in “Baskerville” at Pierson High School
• Alexandra Rychlik in the role of Penelope Sycamore in “You Can’t Take It With You” at Mattituck High School
• Brady Schultz in the role of Mr. Green in “Clue” at Westhampton Beach High School
• Kimberlin Villavicencio in the role of Alice in “You Can’t Take It With You” at Mattituck High School

Lead Role in a Play, Drama or Radio Play

• Maya Alexander in the role of Mrs. Hubbard in “Murder on the Orient Express” at Rocky Point High School
• Olivia Allen in the role of Mary/Young Mary in “It’s a Wonderful Life: Radio Play” at Hampton Bays High School
• Kaitlyn Arichabala in the role of Juliet Capulet in “Romeo & Juliet” at Mount Sinai High School
• Janelly Bednarek in the role of Photographer in “Kodachrome” at William Floyd High School
• Edward Breen in the role of Juror #10 in “12 Angry Jurors” at Longwood High School
• Royce Conlon in the role of Juror #3 in “12 Angry Jurors” at Longwood High School
• Gianna DeMuria-Alvero in the role of Librarian in “Kodachrome” at William Floyd High School
• Sebastian Garske in the role of Hercule Poirot in “Murder on the Orient Express” at Rocky Point High School
• Cole Lafler in the role of Juror #8 in “12 Angry Jurors” at Longwood High School
• Matthew Manzo in the role of Romeo in “Romeo & Juliet” at Mount Sinai High School
• Parker Molina in the role of Joseph in “It’s a Wonderful Life: Radio Play” at Hampton Bays High School
• Brook Tate in the role of “Jo” March in “Little Women” at Sachem North High School

Supporting Role in a Play, Comedy

• Catherine Abbott in the role of DePinna in “You Can’t Take It With You” at Mattituck High School
• Maya Alexader in the role of Dotty Otley in “Noises Off” at Rocky Point High School
• Derek Bergmann in the role of Garry Lejeune in “Noises Off” at Rocky Point High School
• Alex Boyd in the role of Ed Carmichael in “You Can’t Take It With You” at Mattituck High School
• Morgan Dunne in the role of Kolenkhov in “You Can’t Take It With You” at Mattituck High School
• Alexa Field in the role of Essie Carmichael in “You Can’t Take It With You” at Mattituck High School
• Matthew Kelsey in the role of Selsdon Mowbray in “Noises Off” at Rocky Point High School
• Kaitlynn Mazurkiewicz in the role of Yvette in “Clue” at Westhampton Beach High School
• Lila Osborn in the role of Barrymore in “Baskerville” at Pierson High School
• Nico Stavrinos in the role of Mr. Kirby in “You Can’t Take It With You” at Mattituck High School

Supporting Role in a Play, Drama or Radio Play

• Derek Bergmann in the role of Bouc in “Murder on the Orient Express” at Rocky Point High School
• Ashlyn Daniels in the role of Juror #7 in “12 Angry Jurors” at Longwood High School
• Leah DaSilva in the role of Tybalt in “Romeo & Juliet” at Mount Sinai High School
• Emma Galeja in the role of Juror #4 in “12 Angry Jurors” at Longwood High School
• Mackenzie Kling in the role of Mercutio in “Romeo & Juliet” at Mount Sinai High School
• Kiera Klug in the role of Sister Laurence in “Romeo & Juliet” at Mount Sinai High School
• Luis Paz in the role of Benvolio in “Romeo & Juliet” at Mount Sinai High School
• Sari Schneider in the role of Nurse in “Romeo & Juliet” at Mount Sinai High School
• Emma Zeidman in the role of Princess Escala in “Romeo & Juliet” at Mount Sinai High School
• Ben Zozzaro in the role of Perfume Maker in “Kodachrome” at William Floyd High School

Lead Role in a Musical, Comedy

• Abigail Caravella in the role of Cady Heron in “Mean Girls” at Patchogue-Medford High School 
• Ava Catania in the role of Princess Winnifred the Woebegone in “Once Upon a Mattress” at Mattituck High School 
• Ally Cottrell in the role of Ellie Blake in “Freaky Friday” at Pierson High School
• Orlando DiDesidero in the role of Sebastian in “The Little Mermaid” at Mount Sinai High School 
• John Ellis in the role of Nick Bottom in “Something Rotten” at Riverhead High School 
• Emma Hand in the role of Roxie Hart in “Chicago” at East Hampton High School 
• Melanie Hilario in the role of Miss Adelaide in “Guys and Dolls” at William Floyd High School 
• Jayda Hubbard in the role of Sarah Brown in “Guys and Dolls” at William Floyd High School 
• Mackenzie Kling in the role of Ariel in “The Little Mermaid” at Mount Sinai High School 
• Kiera Klug in the role of Ursula in “The Little Mermaid” at Mount Sinai High School 
• Noah Lake in the role of William Shakespeare in “Something Rotten” at Riverhead High School 
• Matthew Manzo in the role of Eric in “The Little Mermaid” at Mount Sinai High School 
• Natalia Neal in the role of Velma Kelly in “Chicago” at East Hampton High School 
• Angelica Paulson in the role of Roxie Hart in “Chicago” at Comsewogue High School
• Michael Pedra in the role of Sky Masterson in “Guys and Dolls” at William Floyd High School 
• Sienna Reefer in the role of Regina George in “Mean Girls” at Patchogue-Medford High School 
• Jadiel Rodriguez in the role of Billy Flynn in “Chicago” at East Hampton High School 
• Emma Samghabadi in the role of Velma Kelly in “Chicago” at Comsewogue High School
• Emma Suhr in the role of Regina George in “Mean Girls” at Southampton High School
• Claire Wagner in the role of Mae Tuck in “Tuck Everlasting” at Miller Place High School

Lead Role in a Musical, Drama

• Aiden Alexandre in the role of Christopher in “Cinderella” at Newfield High School
• Alyssa Austin in the role of Ella (Cinderella) in “Cinderella” at Newfield High School
• Anthony Catarelli in the role of Anthony Hope in “Sweeney Todd” at Riverhead High School
• Nathan Cronin in the role of Edward Bloom in “Big Fish” at Shelter Island High School
• Alexa Detke in the role of Cosette in “Les Misérables” at Westhampton Beach High School
• Sadie Green-Clark in the role of Sandra Bloom in “Big Fish” at Shelter Island High School
• Cameron Hipp in the role of Javert in “Les Misérables” at Westhampton Beach High School
• Noah Lake in the role of Sweeney Todd in “Sweeney Todd” at Riverhead High School
• Cheyanne Metzger in the role of Mrs. Lovett in “Sweeney Todd” at Riverhead High School
• Mia Pazera in the role of Fantine in “Les Misérables” at Westhampton Beach High School
• Meghan Pomroy in the role of Eponine in “Les Misérables” at Westhampton Beach High School
• Brady Schultz in the role of Jean Valjean in “Les Misérables” at Westhampton Beach High School
• Henry Springer in the role of Will Bloom in “Big Fish” at Shelter Island High School
• William Sultan in the role of Marius in “Les Misérables” at Westhampton Beach High School
• Olivia Sulzer in the role of Johanna in “Sweeney Todd” at Riverhead High School
• Chihiro Williams in the role of Her Fairy Godmother in “Cinderella” at Newfield High School

Supporting Role in a Musical, Comedy

• Aiden Alexandre in the role of Kevin Gnapoor in “Mean Girls” at Newfield High School 
• Payton Astromovich in the role of Damien Hubbard in “Mean Girls” at Newfield High School 
• Derek Bergmann in the role of Barnaby Tucker in “Hello Dolly” at Rocky Point High School 
• Sumeja Bytyqi in the role of Paulette Buonufonte in “Legally Blonde” at Hampton Bays High School 
• Georgia Carey in the role of Snoopy in “You’re a Good Man Charlie Brown” at Ross School 
• Anthony Catarelli in the role of Nigel Bottom in “Something Rotten” at Riverhead High School 
• Patrick Conlon in the role of Amos Hart in “Chicago” at East Hampton High School 
• Mia Frohlich in the role of Sally Brown in “You’re a Good Man Charlie Brown” at Ross School 
• Owen Karlson in the role of Thomas Nostradamus in “Something Rotten” at Riverhead High School 
• Cheyannne Metzger in the role of Portia in “Something Rotten” at Riverhead High School 
• Katelyn Oterson in the role of Gretchen Wieners in “Mean Girls” at Patchogue-Medford High School 
• Georgia Salerno in the role of Karen Smith in “Mean Girls” at Patchogue-Medford High School 
• Jenny Salvia in the role of Hugo in “Tuck Everlasting” at Miller Place High School
• Kiersten Schafer in the role of Janis Sarkisian in “Mean Girls” at Patchogue-Medford High School 
• Jaden Smith in the role of Mr. Harry Wormwood in “Matilda” at Southold High School 
• Olivia Sulzer in the role of Beatrice “Bea” Bottom in “Something Rotten” at Riverhead High School 

Supporting Role in a Musical, Drama

• Kaitlynn Mazurkiewicz in the role of Madame Thenardier in “Les Misérables” at Westhampton Beach High School 
• John Ellis in the role of Tobias Ragg in “Sweeney Todd” at Riverhead High School 
• Anderson Hipp in the role of Enjolras in “Les Misérables” at Westhampton Beach High School 
• Evan Pereyra in the role of Gavroche in “Les Misérables” at Westhampton Beach High School 
• Hannah Schmidt in the role of Beggar Woman in “Sweeney Todd” at Riverhead High School 
• Kai Katevatis in the role of Thenardier in “Les Misérables” at Westhampton Beach High School 
• Alexander Lombardo in the role of Lord Pinkleton in “Cinderella” at Newfield High School 
• Ryan Gudelinis in the role of Lionel in “Cinderella” at Newfield High School 
• Blu Giglio in the role of Grace (Evil Stepsister) in “Cinderella” at Newfield High School 
• Darcy Rae Acosta in the role of Joy (Evil Stepsister) in “Cinderella” at Newfield High School 
• Diego Puluc in the role of Adolfo Pirelli in “Sweeney Todd” at Riverhead High School 
• Ari Waife in the role of Karl/Giant in “Big Fish” at Shelter Island High School

Outstanding Performer in a Musical

• Catherine Abbott in the role of Nightingale of Samarkand/Ensemble in “Once Upon a Mattress” at Mattituck High School
• Alexandra Cabral in the role of Teen Fiona in “Shrek” at Greenport High School 
• Dulce Contreras Casia in the role of Shylock in “Something Rotten” at Riverhead High School
• Ryan Darrell in the role of Emcee in “Chicago” at East Hampton High School
• Eddie Giordano in the role of Shane Oman in “Mean Girls” at Newfield High School 
• Erin Hubbard in the role of Nick’s Troupe “Horatio”/Featured Dancer in “Something Rotten” at Riverhead High School
• Damon Lecann in the role of Jonas Fogg/Bird Seller in “Sweeney Todd” at Riverhead” High School
• David Martinez in the role of Pepper in “Mamma Mia” at Longwood High School
• Molly Parsons in the role of Nick’s Troupe “Horatio”/Featured Dancer in “Something Rotten” at Riverhead High School
• Ruby Preddice in the role of Holdak/Cell Block Tango Dancer in “Chicago” at Comsewogue High School
• Hannah Russell in the role of Margot in “Legally Blonde” at Hampton Bays High School
• Ryan Umbarilla in the role of Eddie in “Mamma Mia” at Longwood High School 
• Gabriel Villacis in the role of Master of Ceremonies in “Guys and Dolls” at William Floyd High School
• Sondriel Williams in the role of Minstrel in “Something Rotten” at Riverhead High School
• Ryan Zollweg in the role of Bishop/Prouvaire/Fauchelevant /Ensemble in “Les Misérables” at Westhampton Beach High School

Outstanding Performer in a Play

• Sumeja Bytyqi in the role of Martini/Janie in “It’s a Wonderful Life: A Radio Play” at Hampton Bays High School
• Sarah Fabricatore in the role of Show Announcer in “Noises Off” at Rocky Point High School
• Isabella Harvey in the role of Aunt March in “Little Women” at Sachem North High School
• Rajana Heron in the role of Marjory in “Kodachrome” at William Floyd High School 
• Chas LoRusso in the role of Backup Cop/Shadow Staff in “Clue” at Westhampton Beach High School
• Emmy Shea in the role of Newscaster/Reporter/Shadow Staff in “Clue” at Westhampton Beach High School
• Ava Schmitt in the role of Petra in “Romeo & Juliet” at Mount High School 
• Adreanna Weiss in the role of Show Announcer in “Noises Off” at Rocky Point High School
• Ari Schneider in the role of McCarthy/Backup Cop/Shadow Staff in “Clue” at Westhampton Beach High School

Outstanding Performer in a One-Act Play or Student Run Production

• Mackenzie Kling in the role of Mrs. Peacock in “Clue” at Mount Sinai High School
• Erini Lioudakis in the role of Shelley in “Almost Maine” at Comsewogue High School
• Zoe Mancuso in the role of Hope in “Almost Maine” at Comsewogue High School

Outstanding Choreography

• Jaelyn Hernandez, Ella Menu, Clio McCarty, Lila Ruddy and Valentina Vergara for “Mister Cellophane” from “Chicago” at East Hampton High School
• Jaelyn Hernandez, Ella Menu, Clio McCarty, Lila Ruddy and Valentina Vergara for “Roxie” from “Chicago” at East Hampton High School
• Jaelyn Hernandez, Ella Menu, Clio McCarty, Lila Ruddy and Valentina Vergara for “When You’re Good to Mama” from “Chicago” at East Hampton High School
• Erin Hubbard for Entire Show Choreography (Except for “It’s Eggs” and “Will Power”) from “Something Rotten” at Riverhead High School
• Erin Hubbard for Entire Show Choreography from “Sweeney Todd” at Riverhead High School
• Maya MacCarthy for “The Waiters’ Gallop” from “Hello Dolly” at Rocky Point High School
• Jolie Marturano for “Blow, Gabriel, Blow” from “Anything Goes” at Sachem North High School
• Kaitlynn Mazurkiewicz for “Master of the House” from “Les Misérables” at Westhampton Beach High School
• Izabella Morris for “Voulez-Vous” from “Mamma Mia” at Longwood High School
• Molly Parsons for “It’s Eggs” from “Something Rotten” at Riverhead High School
• Molly Parsons for “Will Power” from “Something Rotten” at Riverhead High School
• Veronica-Sky Williams for “Crapshooters Ballet” from “Guys and Dolls” at William Floyd High School

Outstanding Poster Design

• Zymirah Ali for “Anything Goes” at Sachem North High School 
• Danielle Castro for “Little Women” at Sachem North High School
• Mia Drewisis for “12 Angry Jurors” at Longwood High School 
• John Ellis for “Something Rotten” & “Sweeney Todd” at Riverhead High School 
• Gabriela Galan for “Guys and Dolls” at William Floyd High School 
• Will Garcia for “Matilda” at Southold High School 
• Marin Gilmartin for “Mean Girls” at Southampton High School
• Ella Henry for “Murder on the Orient Express” at Rocky Point High School
• Morgan Lieder for “Chicago” at East Hampton High School 
• Chas LoRusso for “Clue” at Westhampton Beach High School
• Nicholas Mattheus for “Almost Maine” at Comsewogue High School
• Nyah Medina for “Shrek” at Greenport High School 

Winners of Judges’ Choice – TIE

• Entire Show: “Something Rotten” at Riverhead High School
• Entire Show: “Les Misérables” at Westhampton Beach High School