2026 Teeny Awards Nominees

Lead Role in a Play

• Kailtyn Arichabala in the role of Trish in “One Stoplight Town” at Mount Sinai
• Emma Binkis in the role of Olive in “Women of Lockerbie” at Southold
• Edward Breen in the role of Sir Lawrence Wargrave in “And Then There Were None” at Longwood
• Olivia Carley in the role of Ethel Savage in “The Curious Savage” at Rocky Point
• Kolton Chamberlain in the role of Narrator in “Puffs or Seven Increasingly Eventful Years At a Certain School of Magic and Magic” at William Floyd
• Sarah Chami in the role of Elizabeth Proctor in “The Crucible” at Hampton Bays
• Ellie Faulkner in the role of Fairy May in “The Curious Savage” at Rocky Point
• Griffin Fleming in the role of Oliver Rivers in “Puffs” at Sachem North
• Anderson Hipp in the role of William Shakespeare in “Shakespeare in Love” at Westhampton Beach
• Clare Loesch in the role of Abigail Williams in “The Crucible” at Hampton Bays
• James Maroulas in the role of John Proctor in “The Crucible” at Hampton Bays
• Rowan McManus in the role of Sinclair Hemmings in “This Murder Was Staged” at Pierson
• Modupe Ojebode in the role of Vera Claythorne in “And Then There Were None” at Longwood
• Gigi Papazian in the role of Trudy Mitchell in “This Murder Was Staged” at Pierson
• Ruby Preddice in the role of Penelope Sycamore in “You Can’t Take it With You” at Comsewogue
• Taylor Rasmussen in the role of Barb in “One Stoplight Town” at Mount Sinai
• Ava Schmit in the role of Sally in “One Stoplight Town” at Mount Sinai
• Brady Schultz in the role of Henslowe in “Shakespeare in Love” at Westhampton Beach
• Martin Timlin in the role of Philip Lombard in “And Then There Were None” at Longwood
• Lily West in the role of Beth in “Little Women” at Mount Sinai

Supporting Role in a Play 

• Ryan Anres Umbarila in the role of Anthony Marston in “And Then There Were None” at Longwood
• Will Barletta in the role of Reverend Samuel Parris in “The Crucible” at Hampton Bays
• Ashley Bernier in the role of Mrs. Jessup in “The Uninvited” at Rocky Point
• Eoin Datsyuk in the role of Reverend John Hale in “The Crucible” at Hampton Bays
• Morgan DeVerna in the role of Nurse in “Shakespeare in Love” at Westhampton Beach
• Ellie Faulkner in the role of Wendy Carey in “The Uninvited” at Rocky Point
• Riley Finnegan in the role of Lizzie Flynn in “The Uninvited” at Rocky Point
• Blu Giglio in the role of Nina in “The Day the Internet Died at Newfield”
• Ryan Gudelinis in the role of Herbert Stenz in “The Day the Internet Died” at Newfield
• Cameron Hipp in the role of Ned Alleyn in “Shakespeare in Love” at Westhampton Beach
• Jacob Melfi in the role of William Blore in “And Then There Were None” at Longwood
• Parker Molina in the role of Judge George Danforth in “The Crucible” at Hampton Bays
• Heather Moran in the role of Mrs. Rogers in “And Then There Were None” at Longwood
• Samantha O’Neal in the role of Mary Warren in “The Crucible” at Hampton Bays
• Marianna Perratti in the role of Kolenkhov in “You Can’t Take it With You” at Comsewogue
• Lily Rosenking in the role of Mayor Wilson in “The Day the Internet Died” at Newfield
• Gabriela Santos in the role of Young Amy in “Little Women” at Mount Sinai
• Arianna Speciale in the role of Harry in “Puffs” at Sachem North
• William Sultan in the role of Kit Marlowe in “Shakespeare in Love” at Westhampton Beach
• Gabriel Villacis in the role of Cedric/Mr.Voldy in “Puffs” at William Floyd

The Mary Ann Mortorano Lead Role in a Musical Award

• Ava Catania in the role of Wednesday Adams in “The Addams Family” at Mattituck
• Georgia Duffy in the role of Leading Player in “Pippin” at Comsewogue
• Alexa DyReyes in the role of the Sandy Cheeks in “The Spongebob Musical” at Sachem North
• Mia Frohlich in the role of Princess Winnifred the Woebegone in “Once Upon a Mattress” at Ross
• Samuel Gilvarry in the role of Gomez Addams in “The Addams Family” at Mattituck
• Kaelyn Green in the role of Mary Poppins in “Mary Poppins” at William Floyd
• Toni Guarisco in the role of Rosie Alvarez in “Bye Bye Birdie” at Newfield
• Frankie Mattera in the role of Bert in “Mary Poppins” at William Floyd
• Rowan McManus in the role of Man in Chair in “The Drowsy Chaperone” at Pierson
• Faith Mullaly in the role of the Witch in “Into the Woods” at East Hampton
• Noah Pelaez in the role of SpongeBob SquarePants in “The Spongebob Musical” at Sachem North
• Logan Penkower in the role of Ren McCormack in “Footloose” at Eastport-South Manor
• Hannah Russell in the role of Mother Superior in “Sister Act” at Hampton Bays
• Kiersten Schafer in the role of Darlene Love in “Leader of the Pack” at Patchogue-Medford
• Jaden Smith in the role of Scarecrow/Hunk in “The Wizard of Oz” at Southold
• Olivia Sulzer in the role of Elle Woods in “Legally Blonde” at Riverhead
• Lily Trelease in the role of Little Red Riding Hood in “Into the Woods” at East Hampton
• Logan Urtnowski in the role of Nick Bottom in “Something Rotten” at Longwood
• Giuliana Vavalle in the role of Baker’s Wife in “Into the Woods” at Mount Sinai
• Faith Welch in the role of Katherine Blake in “Freaky Friday” at Greenport
• Abigail White in the role of Ariel Moore in “Footloose” at Eastport-South Manor

Supporting Role in a Musical 

• Catherine Abbott in the role of Fester Addams in “The Addams Family” at Mattituck
• Ashley Bernier in the role of Jeremy Potts in “Chitty Chitty Bang Bang” at Rocky Point
• Emma Binkis in the role of Wicked Witch of the West/Miss Gulch in “The Wizard of Oz” at Southold
• Serena Carley in the role of Jemima Potts in “Chitty Chitty Bang Bang” at Rocky Point
• Ally Cottrell in the role of Kitty in “The Drowsy Chaperone” at Pierson
• Kate Deleski in the role of Gangster Two in “The Drowsy Chaperone” at Pierson
• Katerina Fantini in the role of Mrs. Winnifred Banks in “Mary Poppins” at William Floyd
• Riley Finnegan in the role of Truly Scrumptious in “Chitty Chitty Bang Bang” at Rocky Point
• Leonora Gangemi in the role of Gangster One in “The Drowsy Chaperone” at Pierson
• Eli Green in the role of Orin Scrivello, D.D.S. in “Little Shop of Horrors” at Shelter Island
• Eden Greenwood in the role of Paulette Buonufonte in “Legally Blonde” at Riverhead
• Kaitlyn Hauth in the role of Pearl Krabs in “The Spongebob Musical” at Sachem North
• Zoe Mancuso in the role of Fastrada in “Pippin” at Comsewogue
• David Martinez in the role of Nigel Bottom in “Something Rotten” at Longwood
• Lola Moran in the role of Rusty in “Footloose” at Eastport-South Manor
• Heather Moran in the role of Thomas Nostradamus in “Something Rotten” at Longwood
• Modupe Ojebode in the role of Beatrice “Bea” Bottom in Something Rotten at Longwood
• Gigi Papazian in the role of Underling in “The Drowsy Chaperone” at Pierson
• Ruby Preddice in the role of Catherine in “Pippin” at Comsewogue
• Jaxson Schumann in the role of Adolpho in “The Drowsy Chaperone” at Pierson

Outstanding Performer in a Musical

• Vivienne Anton in the role of Nightingale of Samartan in “Once Upon a Mattress” at Ross
• Justin Charles in the role of Featured Dancer in “Something Rotten” at Longwood
• Morgan Dunne in the role of Lurch in “The Addams Family” at Mattituck
• Chelsea Gallagher in the role of Wendy Jo in “Footloose” at Eastport-South Manor
• Anderson Hipp in the role of Patchy the Pirate in “The Spongebob Musical” at Westhampton Beach
• Chava Kowlessar in the role of Jack’s Mother in “Into the Woods” at Mount Sinai
• Conrad Lindemann in the role of Chef Louis in “The Little Mermaid” at Miller Place
• Sydney McHugh in the role of Featured Dancer in “Leader of the Pack” at Patchogue-Medford
• Jonathan Miletti in the role of Jetsam in “The Little Mermaid” at Miller Place
• Molly Parsons in the role of Serena in “Legally Blonde” at Riverhead
• Emily Tracy in the role of Urleen in “Footloose” at Eastport-South Manor
• Gabriel Villacis in the role of Neleus in “Mary Poppins” at William Floyd

Outstanding Performer in a Play 

• Sumeja Bytyqi in the role of Tituba in “The Crucible” at Hampton Bays
• Nathaniel Cote in the role of Giles Corey in “The Crucible” at Hampton Bays
• Rajana Heron in the role of Zach Smith in “Puffs” at William Floyd
• Oliver Josephson in the role of Benjamin in “Ripcord” at Ross
• Jordan Kolsin in the role of Sir Robert De Lesseps in “Shakespeare in Love” at Westhampton Beach
• Kamille Thompson in the role of Bippy in “Puffs” at William Floyd

Outstanding Student Choreography 

• Alexandra Barry for “When the Going Gets Tough” from “The Spongebob Musical” at Westhampton Beach
• Gab Blouin & Georgia Duffy for “Right Track” from “Pippin” at Comsewogue
• Morgan DeVerna & Madison Klammer for “Bikini Bottom Day” from “The Spongebob Musical” at Westhampton Beach
• Katerina Fantini for “Playing the Game” from “Mary Poppins” at William Floyd
• Izabella Morris for “Welcome to the Renaissance” from “Something Rotten” at Longwood
• Izabella Morris & Aubrey LaReddola for “Make an Omelette” (all tap) from “Something Rotten” at Longwood
• Izabella Morris & Aubrey LaReddola for “A Musical” (all tap) from “Something Rotten” at Longwood
• Izabella Morris & Aubrey LaReddola for “Bottom’s Gonna Be on Top” (all tap) from “Something Rotten” at Longwood
• Molly Parsons for Entire Show Choreography for “Legally Blonde” at Riverhead
• Brady Schultz for “I’m Not a Loser” from The Spongebob Musical at Westhampton Beach

Outstanding Playbill or Poster Design 

• Colette Angona for “Mary Poppins” at William Floyd 
• Kaitlyn Arichabala for “Little Women” at Mount Sinai 
• Mia Drewisis for “And Then There Were None” at Longwood 
• Ellie Faulkner for “The Curious Savage” at Rocky Point 
• Catherine Glasser for “The Women of Lockerbie” at Southold 
• Jarrell Gilliam & Molly Parsons for “Descendants, the Musical” at Riverhead 
• Hampton Bays High School Life Skills Academy for “The Crucible” at Hampton Bays 
• Chas LoRusso for “Shakespeare in Love” at Westhampton Beach
• Liliana Maurath Espinoza for “Into the Woods” at East Hampton 
• Ariel Vasquez for “Puffs” at Sachem North

Judges’ Choice Nominees

• Shakespearean Swagger for “Will Power” from “Something Rotten” at Longwood
• In Sync Ensemble by “The Addams Family” at Mattituck
• Delightful Duet Dynamics Between Mal & Ben from “Descendants the Musical” at Riverhead
• Impactful Ensemble by “The Women of Lockerbie” at Southold