22nd Annual Teeny Awards Nominees & Winners

2024 TEENY AWARDS Nominees (Winners in Bold)

Lead Role in a Play, Comedy – TIE

• Maya Alexander in the role of Veta Louise Simmons in “Harvey” at Rocky Point High School
• Nicholas Aspris in the role of Peter in “Peter Pan” at Sachem North High School
• Derek Bergmann in the role of Elwood P. Dowd in “Harvey” at Rocky Point High School 
• Quinn Bruer in the role of Billy Claven in “The Cripple of Inishmaan” at Southold High School
• Michael J. Coppola in the role of John D’Agata in “The Lifespan of a Fact” at Ross School School
• Anderson Hipp in the role of Black Stache in “Peter and the Starcatcher” at Westhampton Beach High School 
• Meghan Pomroy in the role of Molly Aster in “Peter and the Starcatcher” at Westhampton Beach High School
• Laurisa Roalef in the role of Eliza Doolittle in “Pygmalion” at Rocky Point High School
• Emma Rosequist in the role of Mrs. Ethel P. Savage in “The Curious Savage” at Miller Place High School
• Brook Tate in the role of Wendy in “Peter Pan” at Sachem North High School

Lead Role in a Play, Drama

• David Adejare in the role of Harry Thompson in “Murder Takes a Holiday” at Longwood High School
• Rigel Braverman in the role of Foreman of the Jury (Juror #1) in “12 Angry Jurors” at Mattituck High School
• Ava Catania in the role of Juror #8 in “12 Angry Jurors” at Mattituck High School
• Ally Cottrell in the role of Beth March in “Little Women” at Pierson High School
• Leah DaSilva in the role of Raja Englanderova in “I Never Saw Another Butterfly” at Mount Sinai High School
• Ola Rychlik in the role of Juror #3 in “12 Angry Jurors” at Mattituck High School
• Sari Schneider in the role of Irena Synkova in “I Never Saw Another Butterfly” at Mount Sinai High School
• Julia Sheldon in the role of Juror #10 in “12 Angry Jurors” at Mattituck High School
• Myra Tracy in the role of Josephine “Jo” March in “Little Women” at Pierson High School

Supporting Role in a Play, Comedy

• Maya Alexander in the role of Mrs. Higgins in “Pygmalion” at Rocky Point High School
• Emma Binkis in the role of Johnnypateenmike in “The Cripple of Inishmaan” at Southold High School
• Natalie Cervenka in the role of Fairy May in “The Curious Savage” at Miller Place High School
• Phoebe Faint in the role of Bartley McCormick in “The Cripple of Inishmaan” at Southold High School
• Sebastian Garske in the role of Dr. Lyman Sanderson in “Harvey” at Rocky Point High School
• Kaitlyn Heath in the role of Kate Osbourne in “The Cripple of Inishmaan” at Southold High School
• Jocelyn Kaelin in the role of Helen McCormick in “The Cripple of Inishmaan” at High School
• Maya MacCarthy in the role of Nurse Ruth Kelly in “Harvey” at Rocky Point High School
• Kate Pomroy in the role of Smee/Lieutenant Greggors in “Peter and the Starcatcher” at Westhampton Beach High School
• Laurisa Roalef in the role of Dr. William R. Chumley in “Harvey” at Rocky Point High School

Supporting Role in a Play, Drama

• Catherine Abbott in the role of Juror #6 in “12 Angry Jurors” at Mattituck High School
• Andrew Damianos in the role of Juror #5 in “12 Angry Jurors” at Mattituck High School
• Alexa Field in the role of Juror #12 in “12 Angry Jurors” at Mattituck High School
• Matthew Gaudio in the role of Doc Willoughby in “Murder Takes a Holiday” at Longwood High School
• Melody Hammerle in the role of Juror #11 in “12 Angry Jurors” at Mattituck High School
• Carter Kleinsmith in the role of Laurie Laurence in “Little Women” at Pierson High School 
• Ally Konik in the role of Lulu in “Murder Takes a Holiday” at Longwood High School 
• Matthew Manzo in the role of Honza Kosek in “I Never Saw Another Butterfly” at Mount Sinai High School 
• Charles Pasca in the role of Juror #9 in “12 Angry Jurors” at Mattituck High School
• Kimberlin Villavicencio in the role of Juror #7 in “12 Angry Jurors” at Mattituck High School 

Supporting Role in a Play, One-Act or Student Run Production

• Kaitlyn Arichabala in the role of Gayle in “Almost Maine” at Mount Sinai High School
• Leah DaSilva in the role of Glory in “Almost Maine” at Mount Sinai High School
• Orlando DiDesidero in the role of Jimmy in “Almost Maine” at Mount Sinai High School
• Rajana Heron in the role of Beth in “Night of One Acts” at William Floyd High School
• Sari Schneider in the role of Rhonda in “Almost Maine” at Mount Sinai High School

Lead Role in a Musical, Comedy

• David Adejare in the role of Nathan Detroit in “Guys and Dolls” at Longwood High School
• Emma Grace Andersen in the role of Miss Adelaide in “Guys and Dolls” at Longwood High School
• Darchelle Boisrond in the role of Motormouth Maybelle in “Hairspray” at Newfield High School
• Royce Conlon in the role of Sky Masterson in “Guys and Dolls” at Longwood High School
• Ethan Moraitakis in the role of Dee Dee Allen in “The Prom” at Patchogue-Medford High School
• Elyse Nadeau in the role of Morticia Addams in “The Addams Family” at Rocky Point High School
• Jaysen Pommells in the role of Leading Player in “Pippin” at William Floyd 
• Dakota Quackenbush in the role of Reno Sweeney in “Anything Goes” at East Hampton High School 
• Michaela Reis in the role of Sarah Brown in “Guys and Dolls” at Longwood High School
• Jadiel Rodriguez in the role of Moonface Martin in “Anything Goes” at East Hampton High School
• Claire Wagner in the role of Princess Winnifred the Woebegone in “Once Upon a Mattress” at Miller Place High School
• Alexander Yagud-Wolek in the role of Corny Collins in “Hairspray” at Newfield High School

Lead Role in a Musical, Drama

• Nicholas Aspris in the role of Dmitry in “Anastasia” at Sachem North High School
• Ethan Caskie in the role of Jack Kelly in “Newsies” at Riverhead High School
• Sarah DeVerna in the role of Belle in “Beauty and the Beast” at Westhampton Beach High School
• Allie Gilroy in the role of Katherine in “Newsies” at Center Moriches High School
• Tucker Kinney in the role of Grover in “The Lightning Thief: The Percy Jackson Musical” at Pierson High School
• Carter Kleinsmith in the role of Percy Jackson in “The Lightning Thief: The Percy Jackson Musical” at Pierson High School
• Kiera Klug in the role of Benjamin Franklin in “1776” at Mount Sinai High School
• TJ LaClair in the role of Jack in “Newsies” at Center Moriches High School
• Aidan Passaro in the role of John Adams in “1776” at Mount Sinai High School
• Mia Ponticelli in the role of Anya/Anastasia in “Anastasia” at Sachem North High School
• Olivia Trant in the role of Sydney in “Ranked” at Mattituck High School
• Wyeth Zeff in the role of Annabeth Chase in “The Lightning Thief: The Percy Jackson Musical” at Pierson High School

Supporting Role in a Musical, Comedy

• Maya Alexander in the role of Alice Beineke in “The Addams Family” at Rocky Point High School
• Abby Caravella in the role of Angie Dickinson in “The Prom” at Patchogue-Medford High School
• Patrick Conlon in the role of Lord Evelyn Oakleigh in “Anything Goes” at East Hampton High School
• Ashlyn Daniels in the role of Nicely-Nicely Johnson in “Guys and Dolls” at Longwood High School
• John Ellis in the role of Damien Hubbard in “Mean Girls” at Riverhead High School
• Ayla Fideli in the role of Karen Smith in “Mean Girls” at Riverhead High School
• Ashlyn Manion in the role of Berthe in “Pippin” at William Floyd High School
• Liam Martin in the role of Sir Harry in “Once Upon a Mattress” at Miller Place High School
• Cheyanne Metzger in the role of Janis Sarkisian in “Mean Girls” at Riverhead High School
• Michael Pedra in the role of Charlemagne (King Charles) in “Pippin” at William Floyd High School
• Emma Rosequist in the role of Lady Larken in “Once Upon a Mattress” at Miller Place High School
• Lilou Zugmeyer in the role of Janis Sarkisian in “Mean Girls” at Southold High School

Supporting Role in a Musical, Drama

• Kaitlyn Arichabala in the role of Martha Jefferson in “1776” at Mount Sinai High School 
• Jeremy Cruz in the role of Vlad Popov in “Anastasia” at Sachem North High School 
• Anderson Hipp in the role of Gaston in “Beauty and the Beast” at Westhampton Beach High School
• Mackenzie Kling in the role of Edward Rutledge in “1776” at Mount Sinai High School 
• Noah Lake in the role of Crutchie in “Newsies” at Riverhead High School 
• Kyle Manzo in the role of Richard Henry Lee in “1776” at Mount Sinai High School
• Cheyanne Metzger in the role of Medda Larkin in “Newsies” at Riverhead High School
• Victoria Pendzick in the role of Crutchie in “Newsies” at Center Moriches High School 
• Kate Pomroy in the role of Cogsworth in “Beauty and the Beast” at Westhampton Beach High School
• Meghan Pomroy in the role of Lefou in “Beauty and the Beast” at Westhampton Beach High School
• Leah Romero in the role of Abigail Adams in “1776” at Mount Sinai High School
• Brook Tate in the role of Countess Lilly Malevsky-Malevitch in “Anastasia” at Sachem North High School

Outstanding Choreography

• Dan Capone, Georgia Kuzmech, Sophia Montesanto for “The World Will Know” from “Newsies” at Center Moriches High School

• Ricky Campos for “Getcha Head in the Game” from “High School Musical” at Greenport High School

• Morgan DeVerna for “Mob Song” from “Beauty and the Beast” at Westhampton Beach High School

• “Entire Show Choreography” by Erin Hubbard in “Newsies” at Riverhead High School

• Maya MacCarthy for “Tango De Amor” in “The Addams Family” at Rocky Point High School

• Kaitlynn Mazurkiewicz for “Gaston” & “Gaston Reprise” from “Beauty and the Beast” at Westhampton Beach High School

• Izabella Morris and Aubrey LaReddola (Tap) for “Sit Down You’re Rocking the Boat” from “Guys and Dolls” at Longwood High School

• Mia Ponticelli for “Learn to Do it” and “Countess and Common Man” in “Anastasia” at Sachem North High School

• Brady Schultz for “Be Our Guest from “Beauty and the Beast” at Westhampton Beach High School

• Alexander Yagud-Wolek for “Timeless to Me” & “Timeless to Me Reprise” from “Hairspray” at Newfield High School

Outstanding Performer in a Musical

• Sumeja Bytyqi in the role of Jenny Casino/Teen Angel in “Grease” at Hampton Bays High School
• Dan Capone in the role of Albert in “Newsies” at Center Moriches High School
• Kassidy Chamberlain in the role of Featured Dancer in “Pippin” at William Floyd High School
• Kiya Cuevas in the role of Theo in “Pippin” at William Floyd High School
• Katie DeVerna in the role of Silly Girl in “Beauty and the Beast” at Westhampton Beach High School
• Julia DiGirolamo in the role of Maya in “Ranked” at Mattituck High School
• John Ellis in the role of Race in “Newsies” at Riverhead High School
• Georgia Kuzmech in the role of Race in “Newsies” at Center Moriches High School
• Erika Last in the role of Caitlyn in “Mean Girls” at Riverhead High School
• Alexander Lombardo in the role of Bernstein in “Little Shop of Horrors” at Newfield High School
• Kaitlynn Mazurkiewicz in the role of Silly Girl in “Beauty and the Beast” at Westhampton Beach High School
• Molly Parsons in the role of Tumbling Newsie in “Newsies” at Riverhead High School
• Andrew Raynor in the role of Michael Wormwood in “Matilda” at Southampton High School
• Kaitlyn Reed in the role of Featured Dancer in “Anastasia” at Sachem North High School
• Ava Schmit in the role of Courier in “1776” at Mount Sinai High School
• Emily Tobar-Fonseca in the role of Cha Cha in “Grease” at Hampton Bays High School

Outstanding Performer in a Play

• Rene Aguilar in the role of Prodigal Son in “One Stoplight Town” at Hampton Bays High School
• Olivia Carley in the role of Parlor Maid in “Pygmalion” at Rocky Point High School
• Darren Castellucci in the role of E.J. Lofgren in “Harvey” at Rocky Point High School
• Edgar Castenada in the role of Guard in “12 Angry Jurors” at Mattituck High School
• Cooper Foley in the role of Drum Major in “One Stoplight Town” at Hampton Bays High School
• Keira McGarry in the role of Slightly in “Peter Pan” at Sachem North High School
• Lilah Nydegger in the role of Green Bean Queen in “One Stoplight Town” at Hampton Bays High School
• Samantha Palmese in the role of Betty Chumley in “Harvey” at Rocky Point High School
• Emma Zeidman in the role of Mother in “I Never Saw Another Butterfly” at Mount Sinai High School

Outstanding Poster Design

• Olivia Carley for “The Addams Family” at Rocky Point High School
• Johnny Chen for “The Cripple of Inishmaan” at Southold High School
• Catherine Corry for “Pippin” at William Floyd High School
• Gianna D’Agostino for “The Lifespan of a Fact” at Ross School High School
• Nancy Diep for “Guys and Dolls” & “Murder Takes a Holiday” at Longwood High School
• Anna Dwyer for “Anything Goes” at East Hampton High School
• Alexa Feeney for “Mean Girls” at Southold High School
• Lillian Garcia for “Newsies” at Riverhead High School
• Jayda Hubbard for “High School Musical” at Greenport High School
• Kate Pomroy for “Beauty and the Beast” and “Peter and the Starcatcher” at Westhampton Beach High School
• Emma Rosequist for “Once Upon a Mattress” and “The Curious Savage” at Miller Place High School
• Hannah Stumpf for “1776″ at Mount Sinai High School

Judges’ Choice Winners – TIE

• “Gaston” Musical Routine in “Beauty and the Beast” at Westhampton Beach High School
  • Manson Trio in “Pippin” at William Floyd High School